Mugambe’s Fall: A Clash of Legal Systems and the Struggle Between Impunity and Accountability



Uganda’s legal system has long been a fortress of impunity. For decades, it has survived every attempt at reform—not by improving, but by dismantling anyone who dares to fix it.

Enter Isaac Ssemakadde, Uganda Law Society (ULS) President.

His mission? To drag the legal profession out of the mud, rebuild public trust, and hold the entire system accountable.

His first strike? Kicking the Attorney General off the ULS Governing Council. Why? Because how does a government’s top lawyer sit in the governing body of an institution meant to be an independent watchdog? It was a classic case of conflict of interest, and Ssemakadde terminated it.

Image: Isaac K Ssemakade. Photo Credit: Insight Post Uganda


His second move? Recalling all unelected ULS representatives to the Judicial Service Commission (JSC)—a body meant to discipline errant judges. For too long, these positions had been filled by handpicked placeholders who were cozy with the very Judiciary they were supposed to regulate.

Then, the nuclear option—a ULS-led Public Commission of Inquiry into the entire Bench.

That was the moment the Judiciary declared war.

A full-scale investigation into judicial corruption, impunity, and accountability? The Judiciary saw what was coming—a public trial of the very system that has shielded the powerful for decades.

And so, they struck first.

A High Court Judge—who, it has been reported, was allegedly involved in sexual harassment allegations—injuncted the entire process and had Ssemakadde convicted of contempt of court with a two-year jail sentence.

Yes, you read that right.

A judge in a case where he was allegedly the victim, presiding over a trial that could expose him, convicted the man leading the movement for reform.

The Judiciary had gone into full-blown self-preservation mode.

And while Uganda’s legal system was busy eating its own, something very different was unfolding in the UK.

A Ugandan judge—Justice Lydia Mugambe—was convicted.

And suddenly, Uganda got a front-row seat to what real judicial accountability looks like.

No judicial gymnastics. No vanishing case files. No presidential interference.

Just a judge facing the law like any other citizen.

And here’s the real kicker—the UK wasn’t just convicting a judge.

They were sending a message.

Uganda’s human rights record had rotted beyond acceptable limits.

Opposition National Unity Platform (NUP) supporters were reportedly tortured, arbitrarily detained, and held without trial. The UK had already slapped sanctions on key Ugandan officials. And now, Uganda’s backdoor diplomatic channels in London were reportedly frozen.

Word on the street? NUP had played quiet but strategic backdoor diplomacy, exposing Uganda’s entrenched impunity to the UK foreign office—and the UK listened.

This wasn’t just about Mugambe.

It was Uganda being held accountable—one way or another.

Because in Uganda, justice serves the powerful. In the UK, it serves the law.

And so, as Judge Mugambe awaits sentencing on May 2nd, 2025, we extend our best wishes.

Not because of what she did or didn’t do, but because this entire mess is a reflection of a broken system back home.

The Hon. Lady Justice Lydia Mugambe. Photo Credit: Daily monitor



To all who still believe in the Rule of Law—even as the system crushes them—we see you.

To the ULS candidates still battling for election to represent ULS to the JSC—who have outspent resources in what was supposed to be a simple election, but turned into a never-ending war—hold strong.

The Judiciary stalled the election, an appeal halted the process, and yet—hope refuses to die.

Because one day, impunity will fall.

And when it does, it won’t be because of backroom deals.

It will be because of the fearless ones—those who refused to let injustice win.

And when that day comes, we won’t just be telling the story. We will be living it.

Disclaimer:
The views expressed in this blog are based on publicly available reports and sources. Allegations mentioned are unverified and are referred to as they have been reported. This post is an opinion piece aimed at encouraging dialogue and reflection on the issues discussed. The cases mentioned are subject to ongoing legal processes and investigations, and the information presented is intended for general awareness rather than legal conclusions.

More about the author on the about Page.

Do you have stories in your community that we should Blog about, or do you have comments to help us improve on our delivery?,  please feel free to reach out to us through our address which is on the about Page

Comments

6 responses to “Mugambe’s Fall: A Clash of Legal Systems and the Struggle Between Impunity and Accountability”

  1.  Avatar
    Anonymous

    Wonderfully written

    Like

    1. ambrosenen Avatar

      Thanks for reading and commenting. Please share widely within your circles and beyond. Let’s keep the spark of public discourse burning!

      Like

  2.  Avatar
    Anonymous

    beautiful….but don’t make it out like Mugambe was collateral damage….Like She never had a real case to answer….bcoz you risk contracting yourself by alleging that the UK justice system was also “used”…comparing it to ours which voluntarily renders itself “more executive-mined than the executive.”

    Like

    1. ambrosenen Avatar

      Interesting thoughts. The two legal systems are at absolute parallels. The evidence was all too clear. What am saying is that in Uganda that case would probably not see the light of day.

      Like

  3.  Avatar
    Anonymous

    Well, a fine discourse. Our judicial system needs a complete overhaul. I will not comment on the culpability of the two legal personalities you mentioned but both seem to be victims of our skewed judicial ecosystem. One by false the sense of entitlement and the other by lack of it. You wrote what has to be written.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. ambrosenen Avatar

      Thanks for airing your views openly and candidly. Please share widely and subscribe for more Legal discourse thrillers!

      Like

Leave a reply to Anonymous Cancel reply

More posts